Friday, May 4, 2012

My Thoughts on the Tony Nominations


There are 9 productions up for Tony Awards that I have not seen....VENUS IN FUR, ONE MAN TWO GUVNORS, MASTER CLASS, WIT, MAN AND BOY, THE COLUMNIST, DON'T DRESS FOR DINNER, STICK FLY, and THE ROAD TO MECCA....so in categories where these Shows are nominated, I can only judge what I have seen.

BEST PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  CLYBOURNE PARK

What I Would Choose:  OTHER DESERT CITIES


BEST MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  ONCE

What I Would Choose:  ONCE


BEST BOOK OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  ONCE

What I Would Choose:  ONCE


BEST ORIGINAL SCORE

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What I Would Choose:  BONNIE & CLYDE

What Should Have Been Nominated:  ONCE


BEST REVIVAL OF A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  DEATH OF A SALESMAN

What I Would Choose:  THE BEST MAN

What Should Have Been Nominated:  A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE


BEST REVIVAL OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  FOLLIES

What I Would Choose:  JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR


BEST PERFORMANCE BY A LEADING ACTOR IN A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Philip Seymour Hoffman in DEATH OF A SALESMAN

What I Would Choose:  James Earl Jones in THE BEST MAN

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Stacy Keach in OTHER DESERT CITIES


BEST PERFORMANCE BY A LEADING ACTRESS IN A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Tracie Bennett in END OF THE RAINBOW

What I Would Choose:  Tracie Bennett in END OF THE RAINBOW

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Nicole Ari Parker in A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE


BEST PERFORMANCE BY A LEADING ACTOR IN A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Norm Lewis in PORGY AND BESS

What I Would Choose:  Norm Lewis in PORGY AND BESS

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Raul Esparza in LEAP OF FAITH


BEST PERFORMANCE BY A LEADING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Audra McDonald in PORGY AND BESS

What I Would Choose:  Jan Maxwell in FOLLIES

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Elena Roger in EVITA


BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A FEATURED ROLE IN A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Christian Borle in PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What I Would Choose:  Andrew Garfield in DEATH OF A SALESMAN

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Michael Esper in THE LYONS


BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A FEATURED ROLE IN A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Judith Light in OTHER DESERT CITIES

What I Would Choose:  Judith Light in OTHER DESERT CITIES

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Rachel Griffiths in OTHER DESERT CITIES


BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A FEATURED ROLE IN A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  David Alan Grier in PORGY AND BESS

What I Would Choose:  Josh Young in JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Paul Whitty in ONCE


BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A FEATURED ROLE IN A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Judy Kaye in NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT

What I Would Choose:  Jessie Mueller in ON A CLEAR DAY YOU CAN SEE FOREVER

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Chilina Kennedy in JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR


BEST DIRECTION OF A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Pam MacKinnon - CLYBOURNE PARK

What I Would Choose:  Roger Rees and Alex Timbers - PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Joe Mantello - OTHER DESERT CITIES


BEST DIRECTION OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  John Tiffany - ONCE

What I Would Choose:  John Tiffany - ONCE

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Des McAnuff - JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR


BEST CHOREOGRAPHY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  Christopher Gattelli - NEWSIES

What I Would Choose:  Kathleen Marshall - NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT

What Should Have Been Nominated:  Lisa Shriver - JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR


BEST ORCHESTRATIONS

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  ONCE

What I Would Choose:  ONCE

What Should Have Been Nominated:  EVITA


BEST SCENIC DESIGN OF A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What I Would Choose:  OTHER DESERT CITIES

What Should Have Been Nominated:  A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE


BEST SCENIC DESIGN OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  NEWSIES

What I Would Choose:  GHOST THE MUSICAL

What Should Have Been Nominated:  EVITA


BEST COSTUME DESIGN OF A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What I Would Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What Should Have Been Nominated:  PRIVATE LIVES


BEST COSTUME DESIGN OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  FOLLIES

What I Would Choose:  SPIDER-MAN TURN OFF THE DARK

What Should Have Been Nominated:  EVITA


BEST LIGHTING DESIGN OF A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What I Would Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What Should Have Been Nominated:  A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE


BEST LIGHTING DESIGN OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  FOLLIES

What I Would Choose:  GHOST THE MUSICAL

What Should Have Been Nominated:  SPIDER-MAN TURN OFF THE DARK


BEST SOUND DESIGN OF A PLAY

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  PETER AND THE STARCATCHER

What I Would Choose:  END OF THE RAINBOW

What Should Have Been Nominated:  A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE


BEST SOUND DESIGN OF A MUSICAL

What The Tony Voters Will Choose:  FOLLIES

What I Would Choose:  FOLLIES

What Should Have Been Nominated:  GHOST THE MUSICAL






3 comments:

  1. Two thoughts: "Once" sounds amazing, I would love to see that. Other thought: interesting to see the "Spiderman" one here for costumes, does that show get better with some time (after you've thought about it kind of thing)? or not?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not at all....but I do think it deserves credit where it's due

      Delete